| Share facebook | RSS

12
Comments

ambassador Report View

The case of Shies: free report

by Nikolay Dagaev | 09-03-2020 20:33 recommendations 0

Significant changes have been taking place in our country in recent years. The Russian civil passivity has been replaced by unprecedented activity, including in the field of ecology. And the most striking example of this was the so-called "Shies Case".
What is Shies?

Shies is a station of the Northern railway, there are marshes around the station. ¬²reviously, a road made of logs led to it, but in 1971 it burned down. Then the village was decided to close, and its residents moved to the nearest localities. Now no one lives there, but there are many villages and villages within 20-40 km from the station.
How did it all start?

In July 2018, forest was cut in the Shies area. The builders told the local population that a railway will be built on the cleared territory, which will bring waste from Moscow to the new enterprise.

A few days later, employees of the Shies station were informed that by the end of August, 56 cars with garbage from the Moscow region would arrive there. Regional officials did not confirm this, and in Urdom organized the first rally against the construction of the landfill was held on August 26, 2018. The composition of waste from the Moscow region in the end did not come to Shies, but in October, the transport Prosecutor's office confirmed that it was really going to send.
According to the plan, the landfill was to occupy 300 hectares of land and could annually receive up to 500 thousand tons of solid household waste from the capital for 20 years.

How did the population react?

The population of Arkhangelsk opposed it, expressing their negative attitude with numerous protests.

Actions against the landfill were held in different parts of the country. Protesters came to Shies from different parts of the region and since there was no place to live there, the activists set up a tent camp.

The largest event was held in Arkhangelsk on April 7, 2019. This was not the first rally, but the most massive: according to various sources, from three to ten thousand people turned out for an uncoordinated rally.
After the rally, the police began to detain activists, and many received fines. Many activists wear yellow vests similar to the "yellow vests" movement in France, which began in late 2018. In Cheese the protesters used the yellow and orange vests to go over the railroad tracks.

What is the reason for the protests?

First, opponents of the landfill talked about possible harm to the environment.
Secondly, they considered it unfair that garbage from Moscow and the Moscow region would be imported to the region.
Third, one of the main complaints of the protesters is that the regional government "did not consult anyone" and "did not ask anyone".
All this is supported not only by activists. For example, the head of the toxic program "Greenpeace of Russia" Alexey Kiselev believes that"self-construction is taking place in Shies". He notes that in order to agree on the construction, it is necessary to hold public hearings.

How did the authorities react?

Local authorities did not support the creation of the polygon. Back in August 2018, Urdomsky deputies wrote an open letter to the Governor of Pomerania, in which they asked not to build anything.

Alexander Kravets, Chairman of the Council of deputies of the Urdomskoe municipality, said that the Governor had decided to build it bypassing local officials.
The Governor of the Arkhangelsk region, Igor Orlov, spoke for the first time about the construction of the landfill in October 2018. In a conversation with journalists, he called the ecotechnopark in Shies "experimental" for the entire region. Later, he repeatedly said that the landfill will not harm the ecology of the area, will create new jobs, and also noted that " the Arkhangelsk region is faced with the task of implementing the most modern technology for recycling garbage with minimal burial."

In response, activists repeatedly demanded that Orlov be dismissed.
On may 16, 2019, Russian President Vladimir Putin commented on the situation in Shies. He said that decisions on garbage removal to certain regions can not be taken to the detriment of the residents of these subjects:
"Moscow can't get overgrown with garbage, it's a city of ten million. But there is no need to create problems in other regions, either. In any case, it should be in a dialogue with the people who live there."

How did the Shees case end?

Since the end of 2018, there have been regular rallies in Arkhangelsk and other Russian cities, as well as clashes between eco-activists and workers from a garbage construction site.

On March 27, 2019, the deputies of the Arkhangelsk regional Assembly of deputies voted against holding a referendum on banning the import of garbage from other regions to the territory of the Arkhangelsk region. near the Shies station, there was a collision between eco-activists on duty and workers from a garbage construction site. The authorities detained participants of the rallies in large numbers, and many were awarded fines.

On April 25, 2019, the Arkhangelsk regional court declared illegal the resolution of the Arkhangelsk regional Assembly of deputies against holding a referendum on banning the import of garbage from other regions to the territory of the Arkhangelsk region.

After a series of rallies with a large number of people-more than 10 thousand, on January 9, 2020, the Arbitration court of the Arkhangelsk region on the claim of the Urdoma administration recognized the construction of The shies landfill as illegal.

The Shies case, in my opinion, showed that by joining forces, people can achieve justice. Residents of the Arkhangelsk region have protected their interests by preventing the construction of a landfill. However, it is not clear what to do with the garbage of Moscow and the Moscow region. And which region of Russia will be forced to accept this unpleasant "surprise" from the capital on its territory?

Sources:

https://www.vedomosti.ru/opinion/articles/2018/12/10/788816-arhangelsk-protiv

https://www.interfax.ru/russia/661426

https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2019/11/13/82711-moskva-uhodi



 
Shies

no image

  • Dormant user Nikolay Dagaev
 
 
  • recommend

12 Comments

  • Dikshya Parajuli says :
    Enjoyed reading this.
    Thank you for this wonderful report
    Posted 01-04-2020 08:48

  • Rachu Khanal says :
    Thanks for the report
    Posted 26-03-2020 18:53

  • Basanta Adhikari says :
    Greetings Nikolay
    I hope you are doing well
    Very detailed
    Thank you so much for this Report.
    Keep writing
    Green cheers
    Regards
    Basanta
    Posted 21-03-2020 10:50

  • Hema Sapkota says :
    Hello nikolay
    I hope you are doing well!
    Nice report
    Keep writing
    Thank you so much for this report!

    Looking forward to reading some more reports.
    Green cheers!

    Best regards
    Hema
    Posted 19-03-2020 11:49

Kushal Naharki

  • Kushal Naharki says :
    Hello Nikolay,

    I do hope that you are fine and doing great with your works.
    Thank you for your report about The case of Shies

    Green Cheers from Nepal :)
    Keep writing great reports.
    We are eager to read more reports from you.

    Regards,
    Kushal Naharki

    Posted 16-03-2020 02:25

  • Sang Su Mentor says :
    Hi Nikolay Dagaev, this is Sang Su Lee.

    First of all, it is a great lesson that if people gather together, then they can achieve some aims much easier. I think this article explicitly shows this notion. Landfill is very sensitive issue. Have you heard about NIMBY phenomenon? (Not in my back yard).

    To improve this article, you can erase some unnecessary information. This site and report is about the environmental issue. So you can erase how authorities have reacted to this issue and briefly mention all legal actions and people's reactions, and focus on environmental issue in detail. This would be better.

    Good job!
    Posted 12-03-2020 01:18

  • Taehyun Mentor says :
    Hello Nikolay, this is your new mentor Taehyun!

    Thank you for the report. And good to hear your region achieve what you guys wanted! Congratulation! Similar things happen all over the world. In my country, S.Korea, we have conflict because of building a radioactive trash facility in a small city. Radioactive trash facilities and landfills are quite different, but they are both hated by people. The government has a fault! They didn't ask your region resident about these landfills, but my opinion is then where can we build this kind of obnoxious facility? We have to think deeply.

    Anyway, thank you for your report!

    Well done!
    Posted 11-03-2020 16:47

  • Jasmine Karki says :
    Greetings
    I do hope your doing all god..

    Thank yous so much for sharing such wonderful report!!
    Just enjoyed it..

    Go green
    Regards
    Jasmine karki
    Posted 10-03-2020 01:20

  • Pawan Lamichhane says :
    Hello
    I hope you are doing well

    Thank you so much for this report
    Regards
    Pawan
    Posted 09-03-2020 22:31

  • Susmita Adhikari says :
    Hello
    I hope you are doing well

    Thank you so much for this report
    Regards
    Susmita
    Posted 09-03-2020 22:06

Post a comment

Please sign in

Opportunities

Resources