| Share facebook | RSS

13
Comments

ambassador Report View

Your city is flooding. Who gets left behind? [Free Report]

by Theodore Bechlivanis | 11-06-2020 07:32 recommendations 0

When we consider climate change, it¡¯s impossible not to think of the rising sea levels. As our understanding of the environmental crisis becomes clearer, sea level rise persists as its most notorious outcome, and after years of media and pop culture sensationalization, it has also become one of its most feared. 


While some rejoice in the prospect of beaches coming to us - who wouldn¡¯t - it¡¯s important to understand that this is not the primary effect we should expect from sea level rise. As oceans and lakes creep closer to the shoreline, they will destroy residences, services, and roads, leaving millions homeless and unemployed.     And that¡¯s not all: the damage to the infrastructure could make it easy for pollution to spread and harder for existing pollution to be regulated, limiting fishing and other sea-dependent labor in affected areas. In that sense, the expansion of water bodies will lead to the shrinking of human activity that relies on them rather than its development. But human societies are diverse; there is no universal experience of climate change. How much will the impact of sea level rise vary across communities? 


The ifs and buts


When we discuss sea level rise, two basic questions come up: first, ¡°How will it happen?¡±; and second, ¡°Who will be affected the most, and why?¡±. 


Many of us imagine the answer to the first question as a single cataclysmic event. But our data suggests otherwise: sea elevation maps, statistical projections, and other rigid scientific methods tell us that sea levels will rise gradually over time, causing some of the easternmost parts of the world to flood first. Our current understanding of global warming points at excess carbon dioxide in the atmosphere as the main culprit behind shoreline expansion, but there are other important factors to consider, such as the shift in rainfall patterns that is already causing rivers and lakes to overflow.


The second question is meatier. While we may find the idea of environmental disasters as a great equalizer comforting - or even convenient - this notion falls apart fast when we consider the material implications of said disasters. In this case, the loss of submerged land will lead to the displacement of the people who inhabited it; and as these populations move deeper into the mainland, the race for real estate acquisition could devolve into a large-scale housing crisis. So what decides who gets a new house? Let¡¯s look at an example.


Consider a 9-to-5 worker living on the coastline. The rising sea levels have claimed her immovable property and her job, and she is now forced to abandon her coastal city to seek a new home on dry land. How will this person afford rent when all of her assets are gone? With thousands - or millions - of others competing for the same goal, it will boil down to a bidding game between richer expatriates, predatory landowners, the BnB industry, and her, with her lackluster savings and disenchanting government welfare options. Survival in an environmentally insecure world hinges on financial success.


Albeit poignant, this scenario is still one of the kindest. It assumes that our protagonist already had access to employment and real estate; but in a world where job interviews and mortgages are skewed by bias, marginalized groups are losing the housing marathon before it has even begun. Refugees, religious minorities, and members of the LGBT community - to name a few examples - face housing and workplace discrimination that will translate to further disadvantages in an environmental disaster context. However, as the world becomes more hostile and housing gets scarce, there is a particular social class that could suffer the most, and that is people with disabilities.


Disability in a changing world


While we fret about climate change turning our world materially and socially hostile, people with disabilities are already being faced with similar challenges. What does it mean to be a person with a disability in the world as it is now? Modern architecture and infrastructure are still largely inaccessible, job and housing discrimination are rampant, and the resulting wealth disparity between able-bodied and physically disabled adults is striking. In Greece, the poverty and social isolation index for people with disabilities aged 30-34 years old was found to be 54.2%, as opposed to its 32.5% non-disabled counterpart. 


We already discussed how hard it will be for anyone without assets to navigate the post-sea level rise housing crisis. For people with disabilities, their likelihood to be less financially secure than their peers will make the task of finding a new house even more daunting. Those who manage to move to an unafflicted area will be faced with the same disheartening situation as their former homes: inaccessible and unmodifiable apartments, unwelcoming infrastructure, and an awkward municipality that shows no accountability for its failure to accommodate disability. The picture only gets grimmer upon realizing that the job market will be so clogged with the newly-unemployed that disabled applicants will often have to concede their workers¡¯ rights for a shot at getting a job. 


However, even this scenario is relatively favorable. Those who cannot afford to move will be faced with a different set of adversities, including the possibility of further flooding, erosion, the contamination of agricultural soil, etc. For people with disabilities, this could mean the deterioration of an already inaccessible landscape, now burdened with more obstacles and uneven terrain. The treatment of communities that live in present-time environmental ¡°dead zones¡± is telling of how submerged areas and their citizenry of ¡°undesirables¡± will be treated in the future. 


This is a perfect example of what is possibly the cornerstone of disability rights advocacy, the social model of disability. Where the medical model defines disability around an individual¡¯s impairment, the social model focuses on the structural barriers present in society that prevent the individual from living on equal terms with their able-bodied peers. In both cases we examined, people with disabilities will be at a disadvantage because of issues that are already present but will be exacerbated under the threat of sea level rise. 


Studies give us as little as 15 years before sea level rise starts having visible effects on our livelihoods. In certain parts of the world, coasts, rivers, and lakes are already overflowing, displacing thousands in the process. We have the option to be proactive, but with that option comes the responsibility of listening to those that a large-scale environmental disaster will put to the greatest risk. Vulnerable communities have always provided invaluable suggestions on making our communities more inclusive. The least we can make out of losing our cities is learning how to make them kinder the next time we try.


Acknowledgements


Special thanks to Owen Uachave for helping with editing and development.

 

no image

  • Dormant user Theodore Bechlivanis
 
 
  • recommend

13 Comments

  • Sang Su Mentor says :
    Hi Theodore Bechlivanis, this is a mentor, Sang Su Lee.

    What a nice report! This is very creative and new perspective of the natural disaster that is caused mainly by human activities. In fact, all kinds of disasters damage people quite unequally depending on the classes of people. People who are living in strong house are not actually suffered from the flood, but those who are living in the poor countries and weak houses will suffer a lot. You've compared such situation with disabled people and this was quite a good analogy.

    Thank you for your report! ~
    Posted 30-06-2020 21:44

  • Theodore Bechlivanis says :
    Thank you Kushal, I'm glad you enjoyed my article. I hope you're doing well.
    Posted 25-06-2020 07:36

  • Theodore Bechlivanis says :
    Thank you for your feedback, Taehyun! This is a fascinating parallel, and although I believe we are at a point in our progress as a society where we should be able to distinguish between our genetic wiring and discrimination, I understand that one can shed light onto the other to a degree.
    Posted 25-06-2020 07:35

Kushal Naharki

  • Kushal Naharki says :
    Hello Theodore

    I do hope that you are fine and doing great with your works.
    Thank you for your report about Your city is flooding. Who gets left behind?

    Green Cheers from Nepal :)
    Keep writing great reports.
    We are eager to read more reports from you.

    Regards,
    Kushal Naharki

    Posted 18-06-2020 21:06

  • Taehyun Mentor says :
    Hello Theodore Bechlivanis, this is mentor Taehyun!

    Thank you for your various articles! We know that people are always left out of natural disasters such as earthquakes and volcanic eruptions, as well as rising sea levels, and most of them are powerless and weak, such as the disabled and the elderly. It's a sad reality. If you look at books like Richard Dawkins's egoistic genes, we're analyzing human nature in depth from a genetic mechanical point of view, and I think that if you read the book in depth, you can solve this problem of alienation from the minority alienation problem. Of course, it depends on the scope of your thoughts!

    Thank you for the report!

    Green cheers!
    Posted 16-06-2020 14:19

  • Prabha Bhusal says :
    Keep writing wonderful reports!!!
    Posted 14-06-2020 19:03

  • ALOK DHAKAL says :
    Keep writing wonderful reports!!
    Posted 14-06-2020 01:35

Sonika Pariyar

  • Sonika Pariyar says :
    Hello Theodore!

    I hope you are fine and doing great!

    Climate change is one of the greatest challenge world is facing .Its our duty to change our different activities like using organic source of fertilizer instead of chemical fertilizer ,to save the world from increasing risk of climate change .

    Thanks for sharing!

    GREEN CHEERS FROM NEPAL!

    Regards,
    Sonika
    Posted 11-06-2020 23:58

  • Aarati Khatri says :
    Hello Theodore Bechlivanis,
    Hope you are doing great and safe there. Climate change is the burning issues of the modern world. Many research and data has been collected to know its effect in diverse sector. The disable, poor, women are vulnurable to this crisis. All we can do is be the change and inspire other to change and start it from your own.
    Warm regards from Nepal.

    Posted 11-06-2020 12:54

Post a comment

Please sign in

Opportunities

Resources